Monday, February 21, 2011

Lessons from the Legends: Why Buffett Loves Investing in Insurance Companies (Part 2)

I decided to break up the post that takes snippets from the Berkshire annual shareholder letter because it was just too much information to pack into one post. This is a three part post, so stay tuned for more!

The below is, again, the words of Mr. Buffet, NOT mine. He can explain things far better than I could ever dream to.

---------------------

Insurance providers have generally earned poor returns for a simple reason: They sell a commodity-like product. Policy forms are standard, and the product is available from many suppliers, some of whom are mutual companies (“owned” by policyholders rather than stockholders) with profit goals that are limited.

Moreover, most insureds don’t care from whom they buy. Customers by the millions say “I need some Gillette blades” or “I’ll have a Coke” but we wait in vain for “I’d like a National Indemnity policy, please.”
Consequently, price competition in insurance is usually fierce. Think airline seats.

NICO’s Strategy: Pricing Discipline
When we purchased the company NICO – a specialist in commercial auto and general liability insurance – it did not appear to have any attributes that would overcome the industry’s chronic troubles. It was not well-known, had no informational advantage (the company has never had an actuary), was not a low-cost operator, and sold through general agents, a method many people thought outdated.

Nevertheless, for almost all of the past 38 years, NICO has been a star performer. Indeed, had we not made this acquisition, Berkshire would be lucky to be worth half of what it is today.

What we’ve had going for us is a managerial mindset that most insurers find impossible to replicate.

Can you imagine any public company embracing a business model that would lead to the decline in revenue that we experienced from 1986 through 1999? That colossal slide, it should be emphasized, did not occur because business was unobtainable. Many billions of premium dollars were readily available to NICO had we only been willing to cut prices. But we instead consistently priced to make a profit, not to match our most optimistic competitor. We never left customers – but they left us.

Most American businesses harbor an “institutional imperative” that rejects extended decreases in volume. What CEO wants to report to his shareholders that not only did business contract last year but that it will continue to drop? In insurance, the urge to keep writing business is also intensified because the consequences of foolishly-priced policies may not become apparent for some time. If an insurer is optimistic in its reserving, reported earnings will be overstated, and years may pass before true loss costs are revealed (a form of self-deception that nearly destroyed GEICO in the early 1970s).

Finally, there is a fear factor at work, in that a shrinking business usually leads to layoffs. To avoid pink slips, employees will rationalize inadequate pricing, telling themselves that poorly-priced business must be tolerated in order to keep the organization intact and the distribution system happy. If this course isn’t followed, these employees will argue, the company will not participate in the recovery that they invariably feel is just around the corner.

To combat employees’ natural tendency to save their own skins, we have always promised NICO’s workforce that no one will be fired because of declining volume, however severe the contraction. (This is not Donald Trump’s sort of place.) NICO is not labor-intensive, and … can live with excess overhead. It can’t live, however, with underpriced business and the breakdown in underwriting discipline that accompanies it. An insurance organization that doesn’t care deeply about underwriting at a profit this year is unlikely to care next year either.

13 comments:

  1. Buffett always seems to find the diamond in the rough. He's totally unpredictable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. was a really big thing to read but thanks for the info ;)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very nice post, I'm learning a lot keep it up :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. hmm going to read more about the "NICO’s Strategy" it sounds very interesting

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is just me, and I am in NO way any kind of financial expert, but it seems to me that the trend of focusing on shareholder happiness above a good product or customer satisfaction is alot of why we are where we are in this world financial mess. Just my opinion though.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Warren Buffet is definitely a legend. I don't know any Wall Street names, but Warren Buffet is one I do know of.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I've heard about NICO before... that was very nice to read

    ReplyDelete